Quick Comparison Table
G5 Outdoors |
Muzzy |
NAP |
Carbon Express |
Grim Reaper | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
|
| Price | $ | $ | $ | $ | $ |
| Weight | 1.12 ounces | 1.6 ounces. | 0.8 ounces | 0.8 ounces | 1.6 ounces |
| Dimensions | 2 x 1.6 x 1.6 inches | 9 x 5.2 x 1 inches | 8 x 5 x 2 inches | 8 x 3.9 x 1.2 inches | 11.8 x 6.3 x 1 inches |
| Cutting Diameter | 1 – 1 ⅛-inches | max cutting diameter | 1 3/16-inches | 1 inch | 1 3/16-inches |
| Grain | 125 | 75, 100, 125 | 100 | 100 | 100 |
| Warranty | not specified | not specified | not specified | not specified | not specified |
| Amazon FREE Shipping |  |
 |
|
|
|
 |
 |
|
|
|
|
How to Choose the Best Bow Hunting Broadheads on the Market?
When you’re looking to select the best bow hunting broadhead for the money, there are so many options from which to choose.
With the extensive range of brands and models being released by various archery manufacturers every year, it can be difficult to know what type of broadhead will suit your individual needs the best.
The first thing to consider, before you get your wallet out, is whether you wish to purchase a fixed-blade or mechanical-blade broadhead.
These two options can vary greatly, and can significantly impact the cutting efficiency, flight deviation, and impact stability. However, the best broadhead for you can also be a matter of personal preference.
By reading through our buying guide with reviews below, you can become informed about the various arrow tips to help you make a better purchasing decision.
Activity Type
The type of hunting you do can ultimately determine the type of arrowhead with which you will find the best results.
When you’re choosing either a fixed or mechanical broadhead, the speed of it, and the game you’re seeking comes into play.
If you have a lower draw weight (and a resultant slower shooting speed), a fixed-blade broadhead of 1 ¼-inches will improve penetration of your prey.
If you have a slow shooting speed, or you’re new to bow hunting, it’s also a good idea to choose a cut-on-contact broadhead that has minimal resistance for a more ethical and faster kill.
For hunters who have higher draw weights, a wider fixed or mechanical broadhead will be suitable. However, they can cause more damage, with more blood.
Safety
Even though bow hunting can be less dangerous than hunting with a rifle, or another kind of gun, it’s still a sport that requires you to take care and be vigilant.
If you’re not paying attention to your surroundings and your weapon, there may be a higher risk of damage or injury.
When you purchase new broadheads, a manufacturer’s guide to safe use should be included with your purchase. If it’s not, we recommend the following:
Features
The features of broadheads can vary, depending on whether they are fixed or mechanical.
A fixed-blade broadhead might have a blade you can remove for sharpening or replacement, or it might be one piece with an edge that extends from the tip to the rear. You can purchase these as two-blade, three-blade or four-blade options, and even as hybrids.
A mechanical broadhead has blades that reduce drag during flight by folding into the body. They are expandable upon reaching their target, and can often be more expensive than fixed broadheads.
When making comparisons between both fixed and mechanical broadheads, many people often find that mechanical broadheads are the deadliest option.
Efficiency
The efficiency of your broadhead can depend on many factors. Firstly, your skill as a professional or novice can significantly influence your efficacy in the hunting field.
Secondly, the type of broadhead you choose plays a part. A fixed broadhead is quite a versatile option for a range of hunters, but it’s crucial that you buy one that’s well made.
Many hunters have also had bad experiences with substandard mechanical heads. Choosing one with the correct blade size is essential. Typically, they are up to 2 ¾-inches in size.
The smaller the diameter, the more suitable they are for larger game. For example, you are going to get better efficiency with a 1 ½-inch broadhead for elk than you would a 2 ¾-inch broadhead.
Maintenance
Maintenance on your broadheads is crucial. A dull broadhead will not only hurt the animal for a slow, agonizing death, but it may cause you not to get the kill at all.
To ensure your broadhead is in tip-top shape, you should:
Budget
Not all broadheads are created equally, in the respect that some are made from lower grade material or higher grade material. Therefore, you can expect to pay $3.89 to $120 for just one broadhead.
Bow Hunting Broadhead Types
There is no ‘one size fits all’ approach to bow hunting. In fact, as a bow hunter, you will no doubt have a personal preference for the type of broadhead with which you choose to hunt. There are three main types of broadhead – all offering different positives and negatives for your hunting experience.
Fixed Blade Broadhead
Fixed-blade broadheads have cutting edges that extend from the rear of the blade to the tip. They are available with either two, three or four blades which are permanent fixtures of the broadhead. As such, you can sharpen them for better hunting efficiency, but you can’t replace the blades.
Pros & Cons
Pros
Cons
Application
Fixed-blade broadheads are used by a range of hunters – particularly those who don’t trust mechanical broadheads. While they are often not as effective, more and more manufacturers are offering larger, more high-profile fixed-blade broadheads for a better chance of making the kill. They are suitable for a wide range of animals and are versatile for a variety of bows as well.
Maintenance
Fixed-head broadheads require more maintenance than both removable-blade broadheads and mechanical broadheads. You cannot remove the blade for replacement, so to get them working at their best, you need to sharpen them. The sharpening process can take some time and effort on the hunter’s part.
Cost
Out of all broadhead types, fixed-blade broadheads are the cheapest. When you buy online, you can spend as little as $3.
Removable Blade Broadhead
Removable-blade broadheads fall under the same category as fixed-head broadheads, except the blades can be replaced. As such, you don’t have to worry about sharpening your blades out in the field. You can just pop the blades out and put in new ones.
Pros & Cons
Pros
Cons
Application
If you like the durability and strength of a fixed-head broadhead, you’ll love the removable-blade broadhead. It’s very similar in style and shape to a fixed-head broadhead, except the blades can be removed. It can be used in the same way other broadheads can be, but is often more affordable and convenient.
Maintenance
These types of broadheads require minimal maintenance. You just need to ensure you keep the blade clean and free of rust, tune it up for your particular bow, and ensure you have plenty of spare blades to insert.
Cost
In line with standard fixed broadheads, you can pay anywhere between $3 and $120 for a removable-blade broadhead.
Mechanical/Expandable Broadhead
Pros & Cons
Pros
Cons
Application
You can use mechanical broadheads in almost any hunting situation. However, they are mostly preferred by professionals. They are available in a range of diameters, and it takes a lot of force for the blades to open and hit your target. They are suitable for a variety of animals, as well.
Maintenance
To care for your mechanical or expandable broadhead, you have to ensure your blades are sharp. Once they become dull, you can’t just sharpen them. You have to insert new blades. Aside from blade care, it’s essential that you keep your broadhead in excellent condition, with no wear and tear, dirt or grime.
Cost
The cost of a mechanical broadhead is, on average, higher than that of a fixed broadhead. You can expect to pay $13 to $83.
5 Top Rated Fixed Blade Broadhead Reviews
1G5 Outdoors
Pros & Cons
Pros
Cons
What’s Included
Specs
FAQ
QCan they be used with compound bows? AYes.
QCan they be used for large game such as deer? AYes.
Overview
If you’re looking for a cost-effective fixed-blade broadhead that has proved successful for all kinds of hunting activities, these G5 Outdoor broadheads are a good option for you.
They are affordable – with three in a pack – and can make a fast and efficient kill with a good blood trail to follow. While some people noted they were dull upon arrival, the majority of users are more than happy with how these broadheads behaved on a hunting trip.
There are also no parts to maintain, and they are easy to sharpen. They are some of the best bow hunting broadheads for the money.
Reviews
Check out what other people who purchased this product think about it. Read G5 Outdoors fixed blade broadhead reviews.
2
Muzzy 225 MX3-3
Pros & Cons
Pros
Cons
What’s Included
Specs
FAQ
QDo they come with replacement blades? ANo.
QHow thick are the blades? A0.25 inches thick.
Overview
Quality broadheads can often be hard to come by, but Muzzy broadheads fit the bill. They are durable, reliable, and crush bone rather than just rip flesh.
The majority of hunters who purchase these fixed-blade broadheads also like how accurate they are, as well as the no-slip interlocking blades that are made of thick, hardened, bone-crushing steel. The price tag is affordable for the majority of hunters, and they are top-rated on the online market.
Reviews
Check out what other people who purchased this product think about it. Read Muzzy 225 MX3-3 fixed blade broadhead reviews.
3
NAP
Pros & Cons
Pros
Cons
What’s Included
Specs
FAQ
QCan they be sharpened? AYes, but replacement instead of sharpening can reduce the risk of inaccuracy.
QCan they be used with a compound bow? AYes.
Overview
These NAP fixed-blade broadheads are some of the sharpest on the market. While it’s clear to see they will make a quick kill, their speed can often mean they’re inconsistent in hitting the target in the first place.
As such, they are best suited to professionals who know how to accurately gauge trajectories and allow room for inaccuracies caused by a faster travel time.
That’s not to say they aren’t a good option; they just require more time and effort put into the targeting process.
Reviews
Check out what other people who purchased this product think about it. Read NAP fixed blade broadhead reviews.
4
Carbon Express
Pros & Cons
Pros
Cons
What’s Included
Specs
FAQ
QHow thick are the blades? A0.017 inches.
Overview
These Carbon Express broadheads are suitable for a range of hunting activities. They can take down a deer with accuracy and precision, all the while being cost-effective and easy to maintain.
Some customers had broadheads arrive blunt and poorly made, but it appears that the majority of customers are happy with the all-around sound quality of these fixed-blade broadheads.
Reviews
Check out what other people who purchased this product think about it. Read Carbon Express fixed blade broadhead reviews.
5
Grim Reaper Broadheads
Pros & Cons
Pros
Cons
What’s Included
Specs
FAQ
QWhat kind of tip do these broadheads have? AA bone-crushing stainless steel v-notch tip.
QHow many are in a pack? A3.
Overview
These well-balanced, reliable and sturdy broadheads are a favorite with many hunters. Not only are they affordable, but they meet the mark as a hardy and consistent broadhead that’s razor sharp and ready to kill.
Consistency is a big winner with these broadheads, as is the v-notch steel tip for better entry and exit. While the blood trail could be better, all in all, these are an excellent option for any hunter – novice or professional.
Reviews
Check out what other people who purchased this product think about it. Read Grim Reaper Broadheads fixed blade broadhead reviews.
5 Top Rated Replaceable Blade Broadhead Reviews
1Quality Archery Designs
Pros & Cons
Pros
Cons
What’s Included
Specs
FAQ
QDo they come with replaceable blades? AYes.
QDo these require special inserts? ANo.
Overview
If you’re looking for replaceable-blade broadheads that are worth their weight in gold, the broadheads from Quality Archery Designs are it.
Affordable, made right here in the USA, and sturdy enough to crush through bones effortlessly, they are good option for novices and professionals alike.
These broadheads also offer generous pushing power, with the heavy-duty SST construction enough to bring down a deer like a hot knife through butter.
Reviews
Check out what other people who purchased this product think about it. Read Quality Archery Designs replaceable blade broadhead reviews.
2
WacEm
Pros & Cons
Pros
Cons
What’s Included
Specs
FAQ
QHow many blades does each broadhead have? A4.
QDo they come with practice/replacement blades? ANo.
Overview
If you’re looking for good value for money, that’s precisely what you’ll get with WacEm replaceable-blade broadheads.
They are cheaper per unit than several 3-packs on the market, as well as being made of quality materials for better flight, accuracy, and precision.
While the penetration, according to some customers, is not as good as other brands, these broadheads are still a good option for those who prefer replaceable-blade broadheads over their mechanical counterparts.
Reviews
Check out what other people who purchased this product think about it. Read WacEm replaceable blade broadhead reviews.
3
Slick Trick
Pros & Cons
Pros
Cons
What’s Included
Specs
FAQ
QDo they come with field points? ANo.
QIn what hunting capacity are they best used? AFor small and large game.
Overview
These broadheads are accurate, fast, and feature the Alcatraz blade lock system. This is a winning recipe, as they continue to be a favorite for hunters on Amazon.
They fly well, can handle game of any size – from a turkey to a moose – and are affordable as well. It’s clear to see they are some of the best bow hunting broadheads for the money.
Reviews
Check out what other people who purchased this product think about it. Read Slick Trick replaceable blade broadhead reviews.
4
Steel Force
Pros & Cons
Pros
Cons
What’s Included
Specs
FAQ
QHow long are the main blades? A2 3/16-inches long.
QHow many blades are on each broadhead? A4.
Overview
Whether you’re hunting a turkey or a deer, you’re sure to find these Steel Force broadheads meet the mark for all your hunting needs.
They are affordable, made of quality steel, and are exceptionally accurate once set up. They also leave an excellent blood trail, all the while being sharp for easy entry and exit.
Reviews
Check out what other people who purchased this product think about it. Read Steel Force replaceable blade broadhead reviews.
5
Magnus
Pros & Cons
Pros
Cons
What’s Included
Specs
FAQ
QHow thick are the blades? A0.046 inches.
QCan they be used with a recurve bow? AYes.
Overview
These arrows are priced well on the market and tick all the boxes for both novice and professional hunters.
No expenses were spared on using quality materials, and you can benefit from consistency, accuracy, and smooth penetration like a knife through butter.
These broadheads will cut through bone and hide with ease, all the while being affordable for a range of hunters.
Reviews
Check out what other people who purchased this product think about it. Read Magnus replaceable blade broadhead reviews.
5 Top Rated Mechanical/Expandable Broadhead Reviews
1Swhacker
Pros & Cons
Pros
Cons
What’s Included
Specs
FAQ
QWhat is the ferrule diameter at the insert? A0.325 inches.
QHow much kinetic energy is produced with these broadheads? A55 foot-pounds.
Overview
While these broadheads are effective at securing a quick kill, they do take some practice. It can be difficult to ensure you’ve got the right speed and angle, which becomes all the more important when your blades only open upon impact.
They are a good option for professionals who can spend the time to get it right, but for the novice who just wants a quick, clean, and precise shot, there are better broadheads available.
Reviews
Check out what other people who purchased this product think about it. Read Swhacker mechanical/expandable broadhead reviews.
2
Rage
Pros & Cons
Pros
Cons
What’s Included
Specs
FAQ
QIs a practice tip included? AYes.
QDo they come with the shock collar? AYes.
Overview
These broadheads are popular with all kinds of hunters. They fly well, are exceptionally accurate, and provide excellent entry and exit wounds.
They are also affordable with good blade retention, all the while having a sharp blade for a quicker kill.
However, the blades do have problems remaining closed in the quiver, and the blood trail is not as good as it could be. For the price, though, they represent good value for money.
Reviews
Check out what other people who purchased this product think about it. Read Rage mechanical/expandable broadhead reviews.
3
Grim Reaper Broadheads
Pros & Cons
Pros
Cons
What’s Included
Specs
FAQ
QHow many blades does each head have? A3.
QDoes this set come with a practice head? AYes.
Overview
These broadheads are very accurate, making them a popular addition to the backpacks of many hunters.
They do take some practice, but given that you receive a practice tip with the three broadheads in the kit, this is not a problem. They are also exceptionally sharp, leave a good exit hole for a blood trail, and offer tight tolerances.
Every now and again a hunter will experience the blades failing to open upon impact, but this rare occurrence is a small price to pay for what is effectively a well-made broadhead.
Reviews
Check out what other people who purchased this product think about it. Read Grim Reaper Broadheads mechanical/expandable broadhead reviews.
4
Allen Company
Pros & Cons
Pros
Cons
What’s Included
Specs
FAQ
QWhat size o-ring is required? A¼-inch internal diameter.
QHow many blades are on the broadhead? A3.
Overview
If you’re in need of affordable broadheads for a casual hunting adventure, these Allen Company broadheads might be a good choice.
There’s no denying they aren’t the best bow hunting broadheads for the money, but if you’re not banking on scoring that trophy stag, there’s no reason why you won’t enjoy the fun bow hunting can bring.
They fly well, they’re made of durable stainless steel, and although they’re not accurate in both reaching the target and the grain, they are still a reasonable choice for a novice hunter.
Reviews
Check out what other people who purchased this product think about it. Read Allen Company mechanical/expandable broadhead reviews.
5
Carbon Express
Pros & Cons
Pros
Cons
What’s Included
Specs
FAQ
QWhat is the blade thickness? A0.031 inches.
QAre these suitable for crossbows? AYes.
Overview
If you’re a novice hunter who doesn’t want to spend too much money on your first set of mechanical broadheads, these Carbon Express broadheads could be what you’re looking for.
While it can be hit and miss for quality, they meet the mark as a good beginner’s broadhead while you’re still learning to target accurately. However, you will need to make sure all the parts are tight and in place before going ahead and shooting them.
Reviews
Check out what other people who purchased this product think about it. Read Carbon Express mechanical/expandable broadhead reviews.
Where to Buy Bow Hunting Broadheads?
If you’re on the hunt for quality crossbow broadheads for the right price, a simple look online can point you in the right direction.
There is a variety of broadheads on offer, and by visiting Amazon, you’re able to review a range of products to find one that suits your situation the best. You can then purchase them online and have them delivered to your door.
| Leading Bow Hunting Broadhead Brands and Manufacturers |
|---|
Related Guides
